The Camera Button Interaction
Inspired by the concept, I recreated it in Framer and tweaked for further usability.
About a week ago I came across a very interesting interaction concept developed by Astro… they’re calling it “Camera Button”.
Here’s a quote from Astro’s Medium Article, in which they introduced this interaction, describing the basic idea:
“The Camera Button works by detecting the amount of light coming in through the camera. Covering up the camera with your finger blocks all light, triggering a response from the iPad.”
In my opinion, the idea is pure genius! 🙌
In an era, where physical buttons get stripped away, it‘s great to now have a new one available. Also I like the positioning of the button, when the device is held landscape!
Opinions about this were mixed, since it requires the camera to always be active. This obviously raised some concerns about privacy and energy-efficiency, but Astro seems to have handled this well.
After putting in a lot of hard work, they managed to reduce the CPU usage to less than 1% and they handle the privacy concerns by blurring the camera until the data is not recognizable and just usable for evaluating the lighting. Also all the processing happens on the device.
… but still I can imagine, that it can feel weird to not see that you’re on camera.
Maybe I just know too many people having taped over cameras… 🤔
A thought about usability
I thought a lot about how this new concept can be used and realized, what kind of nagged me about the way Astro is using the Camera Button:
It‘s not natural to interact with the camera, when you‘re not actually using it.
I totally get the idea and love the originality, (… and seriously, you can never have enough storage-room for settings) but as a user you would never have the idea to tap the camera…
But when would the Camera Button come natural?
Natural Camera Button interactions
Let me ask two retorical questions:
- When does tapping the camera make sense?
—Exactly! When you’re using it anyway.
- When would you put your finger on the camera?
— Right again! When you don’t want somebody to see what‘s happening.
Two use cases examples
1. Toggle Capturing
Your mum is facetiming and suddenly dad is entering the room — naked!
What would she do? Probably not go looking for the camera toggle-button, but she would cover up the camera…
So why not put the Camera Button concept to use for this? Tapping the camera stops it from recording and your mum won’t be embarrassed!
2. Video Transitions
A vlogger is filming a new clip with his phone. To transition to a new scene, he creates a ‘black’ effect by covering the camera with his hands.
When he removes his hands he magically is somewhere else.
Perfect use case for the Camera Button! On the first Camera Tap, the first clip is done. With the next Tap, the second clip is being recorded and those are getting stitched together and so on…
Would feel natural, right?
Recreating the Camera Button in Framer
Right after I first saw the interaction I was super-excited and jumped right into Framer to recreate it…
Pretty quickly I had a working prototype and kept tinkering around to achieve self-adjustment to ambient light, so the “camera button” differentiates between your finger and normal changes in lighting.
Here’s another quick demo I built for a real hands-on example as described in example #1 — a video-chat, where tapping the camera toggles your video.
Of course, the camera needs to actually stay active for this, but the action would stop your video being streamed to the other person.
Soon in a Framer prototype near you…
It’s still pretty rough, but I’m currently working on a Framer Module, so all of you can dive into this new interaction! 🎉
I’ll update this article with the link as soon as the module is ready for the public…
What’s your opinion on the Camera Button Interaction concept?
How would you use it?